Skip to main content
Banner image for Jonathan Lord

Jonathan Lord

Member of Parliament for Woking

Main navigation

  • Home
  • About Jonathan Lord
  • News
  • Woking
  • Parliament
  • Campaign Emails
  • Advice Surgeries
  • Contact
  • Local Links

First Past The Post

  • Tweet

October 2020

 

Dear Constituent,

 

Thank you for contacting me about electoral reform and for expressing your views regarding “First Past the Post”. I have read your email carefully and have noted the key points that you make.

 

I am afraid I do not agree with the main thrust of your email. Indeed, I support First Past the Post (FPTP) strongly and would certainly not endorse a proportional system for U.K. general elections.

 

FPTP is a tried and tested system that tends to encourage political stability and clear governance, and that also tends to prevent disproportionate influence by minority parties with minimal public support, who typically end up holding the balance of power in PR systems.

 

The British people also preferred FPTP in the AV referendum on the voting system back in 2011 by a very wide margin, although I acknowledge that AV is not a PR system.

 

FPTP is well established and understood by voters, providing a clear and robust way of electing Members of Parliament, and the unambiguous link between constituents (and constituencies) and their representatives in Westminster under FPTP is almost universally acknowledged as a key, and hugely valuable, benefit of the FPTP system. 

 

More often than not, FPTP produces governments with working majorities in Parliament, enabling efficient and effective decision-making, and encouraging robust (even brutal!) accountability at election times where people can easily ‘vote the rascals out’ if they wish to, or, alternatively, they can decide that they prefer the existing governing party to the main alternative on offer.  (In 9 out of the 11 U.K. general elections since 1979 under FPTP, one major party emerged the winner, having secured an overall majority of seats.  On the two other occasions, 2010 and 2017, a government was formed with the support of two parties).

 

In similar vein, FPTP also tends to encourage the existence of a strong opposition party that can hold the government of the day accountable and that can try to prepare itself, and present itself, as a realistic alternative government at the following election. 

 

I believe that all the alternative proportional systems are less transparent, more complicated and less likely to lead to effective and truly accountable government.  After a somewhat inconclusive PR election in Belgium in 2010 it took no fewer than 540 days to form a new Government!

 

Lastly, in these unprecedented and challenging times I think the last thing we probably need is the added inconvenience and uncertainty of a major referendum on PR and/or a complete change to our electoral system. I am sure that PR is something that will continue to be debated as a possibility in the future, especially by academics and by activists for PR, but for now there are more certainly more important and pressing issues to focus on.

 

With best wishes and thank you again for taking the time to contact me about this issue.

 

Kind regards,

 

Jonathan Lord MP

Member of Parliament for Woking

Campaign Emails

  • Access to the EU for British athletes
  • Support for people with MND
  • Support for the terminally ill
  • Pet travel
  • Rent Debt
  • UK-EU trade deal: the fashion and textiles industry
  • Coronavirus vaccines and immunity passports
  • School Breakfast Bill
  • "Fire and rehire" concerns
  • Jagtar Singh Johal
  • UKRI Funding
  • Support for the hospitality sector
  • Napier and Penally Barracks
  • Environment Bill
  • Reopening schools
  • Coronavirus vaccine: people with learning disabilities
  • BTEC examinations
  • Trail Hunting
  • Neonicotinoids
  • Business rates
  • Visa-free work permits for artists and musicians
  • Parliamentary scrutiny of future free trade agreements
  • Trade Bill: 'Anti-genocide' amendment
  • Universal Credit
  • Woodhouse Colliery
  • Coronavirus and the early years sector
  • Food parcels and free school meals
  • Vaccinations for school staff
  • Recognising key workers
  • Coronavirus: testing of arrivals
  • Schools
  • Coronavirus vaccination programme
  • The planning system and the protection of ancient woodlands and trees
  • Use of the whip in horseracing
  • Coronavirus Vaccine Concerns
  • Alzheimer's Society Campaign
  • Pavement Parking
  • Legacy benefits
  • Public Sector Pay
  • Overseas Aid
  • Free School Meals
  • Government Spending Review: Radiotherapy
  • Safe and legal routes for refugees and asylum seekers
  • Animal Welfare (Sentencing) Bill
  • Finn's Law
  • First Past The Post
  • Support for charity funded research groups
  • Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill
  • GMB Union Concerns
  • Support for businesses in the hospitality sector
  • Support for businesses in the night-time industry
  • Beer duty
  • Agriculture Bill, British farming and food standards
  • Food standards and future trade deals
  • Global Wildlife Trade
  • Animal Sentience
  • Overseas Operations Bill
  • Breast cancer related treatment in the upcoming Comprehensive Spending Review
  • Persecution of Christians
  • Fire Safety Bill
  • Government's Strategy on Obesity
  • Close the Loophole Campaign
  • Homelessness
  • Shukri Yahye-Abdi
  • Cystic Fibrosis
  • Asylum Support
  • Bovine TB
  • Coronavirus: weddings
  • NHS pay
  • Uyghur Muslims
  • Trade Bill: NC4
  • Sustainable fishing
  • Fur trade
  • Arthritis
  • Environment Bill
  • A green and fair recovery from the coronavirus outbreak
  • Coronavirus: UK international response
  • Human rights in Bahrain
  • Ethnicity pay gaps and pay gap reporting
  • TV licences for the over 75s
  • Gaza
  • Hong Kong
  • Coronavirus: support for the arts
  • Immigration and Social Security Coordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill
  • Coronavirus: reflexologists
  • Coronavirus: jury trials
  • Grenfell
  • Yemen
  • Arms exports to Saudi Arabia
  • Israel and Palestine issues
  • Statutory assessments in primary schools
  • Understanding the impact of COVID-19 on BAME groups
  • Brexit: transition period
  • Teaching of Black history in schools.
  • Food standards
  • Free school meal vouchers
  • Belly Mujinga
  • Black Lives Matter
  • Climate change - Three Demands Bill
  • Lockdown Issues and the Prime Minister’s Adviser
  • Child refugees and family reunion
  • NHS and the Trade Bill
  • Agriculture Bill
  • Coronavirus and the hospitality sector
  • Coronavirus: schools
  • Coronavirus: Democratic Planning
  • UK-US trade negotiations
  • No Recourse to Public Funds campaign
  • Coronavirus: veterinarians
  • Coronavirus: list of vulnerable people
  • Coronavirus: charities
  • 5G
  • EU Settlement Scheme
  • Coronavirus: Response on Emergency Legislation
  • Onshore wind
  • Childminders
  • Coronavirus: Cremations and burials
  • Windrush Generation
  • Commonwealth Armed Forces Personnel
  • Animal Welfare standards and the UK's trade policy
  • British nature
  • Online Harm
  • Trade Agreement Concerns
  • Middle East Peace Process
  • Environment Bill
  • Hearing Loss
  • Deforestation
  • Dementia
  • Clean Air
  • UK’s Future Agricultural Policy
  • Help protect the oceans
  • Climate Change
  • Asylum seekers & refugees resettlement
  • Voter ID
  • Animal Cruelty Sentencing
  • New mothers' mental health.
  • Caged farm animals
  • NHS and international trade
  • Hong Kong
  • Animal Cruelty
  • Pledge to protect our rivers
  • Live Animal Exports
  • Torture
  • Grenfell - a new housing regulator

Jonathan Lord

Footer

  • About RSS
  • Accessibility
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • About Jonathan Lord
  • Parliament
  • Woking
This website is funded by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA) for the purpose of assisting Jonathan Lord MP in the performance of his Parliamentary duties.
Copyright 2021 Jonathan Lord . All rights reserved.
Powered by Bluetree